Revenue Cycle Management

Best Revenue Cycle Management Software for Private Practice in 2024

Private practices need RCM software that maximizes net collection rates while minimizing administrative overhead — not enterprise systems built for hospital billing departments. We tested the top RCM platforms on net collection rate improvement, denial turnaround time, and total cost.

By MedTech Review EditorialUpdated: May 30, 20248 min read✓ Medically Verified

Revenue cycle management software for private practices must automate the complete claim lifecycle — from eligibility verification and claim submission through denial management, ERA posting, and patient balance collection — without requiring a dedicated billing department. We evaluated five platforms on net collection rate benchmarks, denial overturn rates, average days in AR, and the all-in cost including implementation and monthly fees for practices of 2–8 providers.

Product Comparison

Product	Rating	Price	Best For
athenahealth RCM	★ 4.8	~8% of collections	Full-service RCM outsourcing	View →
Waystar	★ 4.6	Custom enterprise pricing	Mid-size private groups	View →
Kareo RCM (Tebra)	★ 4.4	From $200/mo	Independent practices	View →
AdvancedMD RCM	★ 4.3	From 5% of collections	Practices with complex payer mix	View →
CureMD RCM	★ 4.1	From $199/mo	Budget-conscious private practices	View →

Pros & Cons

✓ Pros

Automated eligibility verification at scheduling catches inactive insurance before the patient arrives
AI-powered claim scrubbing identifies coding errors and modifier issues before electronic submission
Denial management worklists automatically prioritize high-value denials for staff follow-up
Patient payment plans and text-to-pay links accelerate patient balance collection by 35–50%

✗ Cons

Percentage-of-collections models (athenahealth, AdvancedMD) cost more than flat fees for high-revenue practices
Switching RCM platforms mid-year creates 60–90 day transition periods of reduced billing efficiency
Complex payer contracts require manual fee schedule entry that most platforms do not automate

Frequently Asked Questions

What net collection rate should a well-run private practice achieve?▾

A net collection rate (NCR) of 95–98% is considered excellent for most specialties. NCR below 90% indicates significant revenue leakage from uncollected copays, denied claims, or timely filing failures. athenahealth clients report average NCRs of 97.6% in independent audits, compared to an industry average of 91–93% for self-managed billing.

What is a reasonable days-in-AR target for a private practice?▾

Days in accounts receivable (AR) below 35 days is considered excellent for most outpatient specialties. Days in AR above 50 suggests claim submission delays, denial accumulation, or insufficient follow-up staffing. Waystar and athenahealth both include real-time AR aging dashboards that identify which payers and denial codes are driving AR growth.

Is outsourced RCM worth the cost for a private practice?▾

For practices collecting $500,000+ annually, outsourced RCM typically nets 3–8% more revenue than self-managed billing, despite the 4–8% service fee, due to lower denial rates and faster follow-up. Practices collecting below $300,000/year often find in-house billing with good software more cost-effective than full outsourcing.

How does Waystar differ from athenahealth for private practice RCM?▾

Waystar is a clearinghouse-based RCM platform that connects to your existing EHR and adds claim submission, denial, and analytics layers without replacing your clinical software. athenahealth is an all-in-one EHR + RCM system where you replace both your clinical and billing platforms. Waystar is preferred by practices that want to keep their EHR; athenahealth is best for practices open to a full platform switch.

Our Top Pick

athenahealth RCM — Highest Net Collection Rate in Private Practice

athenahealth's performance-based RCM service achieves a 97.6% average net collection rate. You pay only 7–9% of collections — so their incentives are directly aligned with your revenue.

Request a Free athenahealth RCM Analysis →

* Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.